Customer Statements

Maddie

“My husband and I both switched to Erie a couple weeks ago with Jennifer. She was amazing in making the process simple and smooth and went above and beyond to make sure we were satisfied. She is amazing and I definitely recommend!!! She is the sweetest person you’ll come across ESPECIALLY dealing with insurance people, most of them want to just take your money and go on about their day, not this one."

Rudolf

" By far beats all other insurance company's"

Jackie

“We just recently switched to Steele Insurance Agency in October after being with our former agency for 30 years! Rhonda and Betsey made the process as easy as possible, and were ready to answer any questions when I had them. I highly recommend then to anyone looking for an insurance agency that puts cusomters first!”

Rosanna

Betsey Johnson & The Steele Insurance Team have been a wonderful resource for us - first through our Business Policy, and more recently we have moved our home & auto to their group as well after a not so good experience with another firm - We were absolutely thrilled to find someone as thorough and knowledgeable of all aspects of insurance coverage - Betsey took the time to get the details right and explain everything with great care for each area - and more so, has an immense focus on customer service - she brings back the humanity and personal interaction that is rare these days in any business - you aren't just a statistic to her - she truly cares about her clients and it very much shows with the service that she provides. I can't say enough great things about Betsey & Steele - Thank You So Much!!!

Hanover Computers

The Steele Insurance Agency has handled our commercial, residential, and car insurance for many, many years. Betsey, Alice, and Rhonda are very friendly and really know their stuff. If you need commercial, residential, or car insurance, call the Steele Insurance Agency!

Lisa

Steele saved me over $1k a year on car insurance! Super easy to work with.

Peggy

Top notch customer service by Steele and I literally saved thousands!

Betty

They were fantastic to work with, highly recommend! Great customer service. Thanks!!!